An electric charge has no screw sense—a comment on the twistfree formulation of electrodynamics by da Rocha & Rodrigues

MOspace/Manakin Repository

Breadcrumbs Navigation

An electric charge has no screw sense—a comment on the twistfree formulation of electrodynamics by da Rocha & Rodrigues

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10355/5130

[+] show full item record


Title: An electric charge has no screw sense—a comment on the twistfree formulation of electrodynamics by da Rocha & Rodrigues
Author: Itin, Yakov; Obukhov, Yuri N.; Hehl, F. W. (Friedrich W.), 1937-
Keywords: polar and axial vectors
differential forms with twist
premetric electrodynamics
Date: 2010-01-27
Publisher: Wiley-Blackwell
Citation: Annalen der Physik, 27 January 2010
Abstract: Da Rocha and Rodigues (RR) claim (i) that in classical electrodynamics in vector calculus the distinction between polar and axial vectors and in exterior calculus between twisted and untwisted forms is inappropriate and superfluous, and (ii) that they can derive the Lorentz force equation from Maxwell's equations. As to (i), we point out that the distinction of polar/axial and twisted/untwisted derives from the property of the electric charge of being a pure scalar, that is, not carrying any screw sense. Therefore, the mentioned distinctions are necessary ingredients in any fundamental theory of electrodynamics. If one restricted the allowed coordinate transformations to those with positive Jacobian determinants (or prescribed an equivalent constraint), then the RR scheme could be accommodated; however, such a restriction is illegal since electrodynamics is, in fact, also covariant under transformations with negative Jacobians. As to (ii), the “derivation” of the Lorentz force from Maxwell's equations, we point out that RR forgot to give the symbol F (the field strength) in Maxwell's equations an operational meaning in the first place. Thus, their proof is empty. Summing up: the approach of RR does not bring in any new insight into the structure of electrodynamics.
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/10355/5130
ISSN: 0003-3804

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

[+] show full item record